From My Heart To Yours

The Beauty of Imperfect Love

A Photographer’s Reflections on Gratitude, Acceptance, and the People We Hold Dear

By Tim Auman

Most of you know that in my spare time I teach photography at the Sawtooth School for Visual Arts. But what you probably don’t know is that the classes I teach are not the “everything you need to know to operate your digital camera” variety. Instead, we explore something called the ontology of photography. Ontology is the branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of being and existence. The ontology of photography asks something more fundamental than how photographs are made, what they represent, or whether they are beautiful. It asks: What is a photograph, at the deepest level of its being? And perhaps more importantly, what kind of relationship does a photograph establish between the world, the photographer, and the person who encounters the image? These questions become especially interesting when we approach photography as a contemplative practice rather than simply a means of representation. That’s definitely more than you probably wanted to know, but it offers a little glimpse into my world beyond Danbury Community Church.

Most photographers are gear nerds at heart, meaning we love our camera equipment. We have our favorites, our babies, the cameras we treat almost like members of the family. I’m no exception. My favorite camera is a 1971 Leica M5, a 35mm film rangefinder camera that, after fifty-five years, still creates extraordinary images. It’s a beautifully engineered, mostly mechanical piece of photographic history that feels as familiar in my hands as an old friend. Ask me nicely sometime, and I might even let you hold it.

But here’s the thing. One of the reasons my affection for my M5 is so strong and enduring comes down to a paradoxical but telling detail: how little I actually expect of it. I expect it to make great images. That’s pretty much it. Unlike what I sometimes ask of the human beings in my life, I don’t need my favorite camera to understand my idiosyncrasies, share my opinions about politics, or agree with me about how to create next Sunday’s sermon or spend the Thanksgiving holidays. I simply want it to take beautiful pictures, feel familiar in my hands, and make that wonderful little clicking sound when I press the shutter release. Is this true love? Kinda, but probably not.

By contrast, we often place an almost impossible burden of expectation on the people we love. We want them to understand us intuitively, share our convictions, appreciate our peculiarities, and somehow see the world through the same lens we do. We hope they’ll agree with our politics, share our opinions about family and friends, and respond to life’s complications much as we would. And when they inevitably fall short of these expectations, as we all do, disappointment can quietly give way to frustration, resentment, and even a withholding of affection. Somewhere along the way, we begin to confuse loving someone with needing them to become a reflection of ourselves, forgetting that the beauty of a relationship often lies in the very differences we struggle to embrace.

I’m guessing that, as people of faith, there might be another way of approaching all this, especially as we prepare to gather around Thanksgiving tables with family and friends. These gatherings can be wonderful occasions of gratitude and affection, but they can also remind us just how complicated loving one another can be. After all, few things test our spiritual maturity quite like a Thanksgiving dinner with people who see the world differently than we do.

So perhaps we might consider an alternative. By becoming a little more thoughtful about what we expect from our relationships, we may actually become better able to honor the deeper claims of love. Guided, somewhat improbably, by my affection for an old camera, we might recognize that a bond between two people can be deep and meaningful precisely because it doesn’t have to extend to every practical detail of existence. We don’t have to agree about everything to love one another deeply. We don’t have to share the same politics, preferences, or peculiarities to recognize the goodness in another human being. And when we loosen our grip on those expectations, we make room for something far more important: the simple human longing to be lovingly held, warmly embraced, and accepted even when our opinions, personalities, or emotional lives don’t quite line up.

Perhaps that’s one of the quieter lessons of Thanksgiving. Gratitude isn’t simply about appreciating the people who make our lives easier or who happen to agree with us. It’s also about recognizing the gift of those wonderfully imperfect human beings whose lives have become intertwined with our own. Love, at its best, allows people to be themselves without constantly insisting that they become more like us. And sometimes the most gracious thing we can do around the Thanksgiving table is to set aside our need to be right and simply enjoy one another’s company.

If you were ever tempted to despair about the human capacity for love, you might recover a little hope by considering the kindness and compassion I witness every Sunday at our little Danbury Community Church. I see it in the way you care for one another, in your generosity toward neighbors, in the quiet acts of kindness that often go unnoticed, and in the warmth with which you welcome people into this community.

None of us is perfect, of course, but perhaps that’s precisely the point. Love doesn’t require perfection. It asks only that we continue making room for one another.

Yep, the world around us can sometimes leave us feeling downright depressed. The headlines can be discouraging, our differences can seem overwhelming, and the future can feel uncertain. But then Sunday comes, and I find myself surrounded by the familiar faces, laughter, hugs, and generous spirits of my DCC family. And somehow, the world begins to look a little brighter.

One good dose of my DCC family usually does the trick.  And for that, I am deeply grateful.